In today's post, we are going to dig deep into the meanings and differences between Calligraphy, Lettering, and Typography, so we can understand where they come from and why it is important to tell them apart.
Hand Lettering vs. Calligraphy and typography, what each one of them is and what are the differences.
I warn you; this one is going to be a long one! But bear with me, because I think this is the most BASIC thing we have to understand as beginners.
And since I want to be as accurate as possible, we will examine each one and dig in books that will explain each term better.
One of the biggest misconceptions for people that are unfamiliar with design work is that Calligraphy, Lettering, and Typography are interchangeable words, all in the same category and with the same meaning.
But the world of letter-making is broken down into a few different categories of artists that are foundationally different: calligraphers, letterers and type designers.
While letterers and calligraphers both create custom work involving letters, type designers construct systems of letters (knows as typefaces) that work in endless combinations and output as ‘fonts' (read about the difference between typeface and font below).
Table of contents
1 – Calligraphy vs. Lettering
2 – Book references to each term
3 – Calligraphy definition
4 – Lettering definition
5 – Typography definition
6 – The difference between Font and typeface?
7 – Common mistakes
8 – What is brush lettering?
9 – Why is it used incorrectly?
10 – What is brush calligraphy?
11 – What is faux calligraphy?
12 – What is Chalk lettering?
13 – My mistakes as a beginner
14 – Why writing this post?
Throughout this process we will focus on the most significant difference between the 3, but first on Calligraphy vs. lettering.
Calligraphy vs. Lettering
In a nutshell, calligraphers WRITE letters and letterers DRAW them, that is the essential difference between these art forms, but to really see the difference when we look at someone making letters, we need to dig to the bottom and address a few crucial points.
Most lettering artists start with calligraphy, because understanding how letters are constructed and behave, along with where the thick and thins are located, is an essential part of ANY work involving letters.
And while it is okay to only specialize in one of them, it can be harder to start making letters when the construction of each one doesn't make sense.
Most people only think of ‘script style' when referring to Calligraphy, but there’s a big number of styles that can be written in calligraphy that are not script style.
TIP: If you are interested in a good book with examples of different calligraphic styles, I recommend The Art of Calligraphy: A Practical Guide to the Skills and Techniques by David Harris, you can see additional pictures of all the recommended books in this post.
Book references to each term
I believe that the most accurate way to research the terms is by following the definition so the experts in the field, that is why I created a full section of references that we can study.
In Calligraphy, the way we use a writing tool, with pressure differences in the motions as we ‘write' each of their parts, is what gives us the different thickness, no matter the style we are writing (sans serif, serif, copperplate, etc.)
On her book ‘Modern Calligraphy: Everything You Need to Know to Get Started in Script Calligraphy,' artist Molly Suber Thorpe explains:
“Historically, calligraphy was relatively inflexible, with classical styles taught as complete alphabets with established letterforms. The aim was uniformity, and practice was about striving towards the ‘correct”, predetermined shape.” but “Twenty-first-century artist frequently creates their own alphabets to reflect their personal aesthetics and personality.” – Molly Suber Thorpe author of Modern Calligraphy
Now, what better way to dig deep than to read what other experts have to say about the differences between Calligraphy and lettering.
The first reference can be found in the book ‘The ABC of custom lettering‘ by Spanish artist Ivan Castro. Castro separates his book in a “Calligraphy” and a “Lettering” chapter, to make sure we can identify them as something completely different.
He begins with calligraphy because that is the best way to understand letter construction like we mentioned above, in the ‘Drawing letters' chapter (aka Lettering) he states:
“In making the transition from writing letters to drawing them, we need to understand the differences between this forms. When we do calligraphy, our manual skill is very important, because we can’t correct what we have done, but when we draw letters, we do have the chance to correct, erase, ink over, criticize, erase and draw again. It’s a completely different method of working, even though the objective — making letters by hand — is the same.” – Ivan Castro author of The ABC of custom lettering
The big takeaway from his words is that in lettering, we can correct, and re-work individual letters and composition. While in Calligraphy, you can also ‘plan' the artwork, when making it.
You cannot correct or erase because most of the time, you are using ink with either a pointed/flat pen, brush pen, or any other specialty tool with ink.
“ Lettering refers to a unique personalized typographic expression, made for a certain application by combining shapes and graphic elements, in order to convey a certain attribute, message or idea.” – Martina Flor author of the golden secrets of lettering
I also wanted to add this quote by Vance Studley,
Calligraphy is a skill. This skill involves touch, pressure, hand movement, unity, and that elusive quality we term “beauty.” (Vance Studley, Left-Handed Calligraphy (NY: Dover, 1991), p. 8) found at Calligraphy-skills.com
Here you can see a graphic I made with the easier way to define each one
So now that we have a better understanding let's define them:
Writing letters; no matter the tools we use; dip pen, flat pen, brush marker, regular brush, etc., we make a stroke for every essential part of the letter, sometimes a whole letter or word.
No matter the style; formal, classical, experimental, modern, there is no erasing, nor correction of the letters. Calligraphy embraces the spontaneity of executing letterforms according to a model or freehand. Using muscle memory and repetition, to execute set ‘styles' of letters.
“Kalli- is a Greek root meaning “beautiful,” and “beautiful” in the case of calligraphy means artistic, stylized, and elegant.” – Merriam Webster
Drawing letters; in this case, we build the letters using as many strokes as necessary. We sketch, erase, correct, add, repeatedly until we are happy with the letterform and the connections between them.
In lettering, the relations of the letters are unique; we create one-of-a-kind letters and letter-connections that are made (drawn, painted, carved) for a single artwork piece.
Generally, when we talk about typography, we are referring to the use of letters created by type designers, and the arrangements of those letters that have been established by them. Type designers create systems of characters and make letters that work in endless combinations.
“In lettering, the letters are usually drawn, and for a specific context. In type, repeating letters typically have the same shapes. Fonts are capable of emulating the variation of lettering through alternates and ligatures, but they are still type: a system of pre-made letters that can be reproduced again and again.” – TypeNetwork
What is Type? Prefabricated letters that are made to be reused many times and in any order.
The difference between Font and typeface?
I've seen more and more people reference different styles of lettering or even different styles of modern calligraphy as “fonts” and while if programmed they COULD become a font.
Fonts are only a small portion of a typeface, so let's define them to see the difference.
Typeface: A family of fonts, usually with different weights and styles (bold, italic, thin, etc.)
Font: Is a specific weight or style of a typeface ( Helvetica Bold, Helvetica italic, etc.)
A huge misconception in the beginner community is that the tool used to create the letters is what determines the name or family. (ex. Letters made with brush pens are ‘brush lettering', scripts created with pencils are ‘faux calligraphy')
Most people don't understand that Lettering and Calligraphy are NOT defined by the tools we are using to create the letters, BUT by the method, we are using to construct them.
To reiterate the points we made above:
LETTERING: Drawing letters, using the necessary number of revisions, modifications and usually born out of several thumb sketch ideas.
CALLIGRAPHY: Writing letters, whether, in one stroke or the deconstruction of several strokes, there is no erasing or re-adjusting.
I think the misconception comes because some people have only the pointed and flat pen associated with calligraphy, so when they see someone using a different tool, they automatically think that it has to be called differently (in this case, most times they use ‘lettering').Now, it’s entirely possible to grab a soft carbon pencil and apply low and hard pressure to create thin and thick lines (the basic concept of calligraphy), but we are not going to call that ‘pencil lettering' because it was created with a pencil, right?
Another big misconception I would like to address before we keep moving is that to be a lettering artist; you HAVE to be a calligrapher and vise Versa.
Granted, while this is not true, it does help tremendously to understand and get better at both in order to be a well-rounded artist.
What is brush lettering?
Brush lettering, as it is popularly shared in social media, is not actually lettering (Like on the right side of my comparison picture above).
That would be considered Brush Calligraphy.
The actual origin of the term ‘Brush lettering' comes from the ’50s, and '60s when sign painting started as a profession in the USA.
The term was properly used then, because as the name implies, they were doing ‘lettering' using real brushes and paint, to paint signs.
With careful strokes, they would recreate their hand-drawn sketches on walls, windows, signs or just any surface where their artwork was needed.
Sign painting is an art and trade that I admire so much, and even though the basics of lettering and letter constructions are the same. The final execution is mesmerizing to me.
A good short read is this post “Brief history on sign painting‘.
And if you have an hour to spare, I highly recommend the ‘Sign painters‘ documentary; there’s something so awesome about seeing an artist emerged on a piece of work and sharing their passion for letters.
We definitely don't have enough of this kind of documentaries for creatives.
“Featuring interviews with more than two dozen artists from across the United States, “Sign Painters” is the first film to explore the history of the time-honored craft of sign painting. Documenting these dedicated practitioners, their methods, and their appreciation for quality and craftsmanship, the film profiles sign painters young and old, revealing the growing renaissance in the trade.” – Sign painters documentary
Why is it used incorrectly?
Now that we understand the difference between Lettering and Calligraphy, it is easier to recognize that the term ‘Brush Lettering' is used incorrectly on many occasions and this is very confusing for beginners!
I see so many people that think that they are learning ‘lettering,' but they are actually doing ‘Calligraphy' to be exact ‘Brush Calligraphy.'
What is brush calligraphy?
Calligraphy done with a brush is originally a traditional Chinese style (this is why many of the big brands of brush pens come from Japan and China).
The downside for Western calligraphers was that the use of those brushes would translate to bigger letters, and this made it hard to use on little details (envelopes, invitations, etc.)
So instead, western calligraphy started to focus more on writing using pointed & flat pens (or dip nibs).
With the introduction of brush pens, especially fude pens with a small brush, it became super popular and easy to use them instead of pointed pens while learning calligraphy.
There are less prep work and limited nibs to clean and worry about storing.
Now we see people making calligraphy with a brush pen everywhere in social media, and many call it “brush lettering.”
But like we already covered, that is NOT the right term if what they are doing is continual writing with no erasing, it would be BRUSH CALLIGRAPHY.
I know that I might sound a little passionate, and many people are going to roll their eyes because it’s just a word…right?
BRUSH CALLIGRAPHY instead of BRUSH LETTERING.
Well, in this case, that little word changes the whole meaning and the profession of the artist using it, so it is a BIG DEAL :D
Remember that we already talked about how not every letterer is a calligrapher and vice versa.
Just like photography and videography, they both use the same tools, but the results are entirely different.
They both have to master completely different factors to create their end product. Sure one of them will have an easier time transitioning from one to the other, but they use an entirely different setting in their tools and process.
In this case, it is the same.
What is faux calligraphy?
Now, with this term, I had a hard time, not only trying to pinpoint where it originated from but also understanding why people would even use it?
Now bear with me, I am talking from the perspective of learning lettering first. To me, it was so evident that what most people were showing, and calling ‘faux-calligraphy' was simply ‘lettering.'
So maybe calling it faux calligraphy made sense to a calligrapher? Not sure.
Anyhow, no matter if it makes sense or not, there is no such thing as faux calligraphy.
When you make script letters by drawing a skeleton, adding weight with a pencil, and then filling in what looks like calligraphy you are basically doing LETTERING.
That is the exact process lettering artists use to create their pieces.
If you recall the definition of both Calligraphy and Lettering, you can clearly see that what we described is just lettering. We also covered the specific way we construct letters is what determines the difference.
Now, we could get super technical and have a passionate discussion over the way that some Calligraphy pieces are created.
Because some Calligraphy artist plan, trace, and correct before going to ink, maybe it would become something else, but the bottom line is that if the letter has been ‘drawn' corrected, erased, drawn again, it’s lettering.
So let’s ditch the ‘faux calligraphy' term ok?
And since we are going over all terms, let's revise Chalk lettering too.
What is Chalk lettering?
As the name implies, Chalk-lettering is when we create lettering pieces with Chalk.
Finally, this one is actually used correctly! And it’s easy to identify; when you are drawing with chalk, you pretty much follow the same techniques as you would lettering with conventional tools.
The only difference is that you might use shading and techniques that can only be obtained with chalk.
Granted, there are brush paints in different colors, or we could paint with regular paint on a chalkboard, and again we would migrate to a completely different family because that would be more of a sign painting technique.
My letter story and mistakes
In my case, I started my journey with lettering while attending design school in Chile (I am an Industrial Designer by trade), I slowly ‘dipped' my toes into calligraphy (puns, anyone? No, ok).
Because I didn't have a ‘proper' Calligraphy background, I looked up to other artists practicing and sharing their Calligraphy and lettering work.
I saw a lot of artists creating letters with brush pens. They called it ‘Brush lettering' and since I figured it must be an English translation issue, I didn't question it!
But it made no sense because I knew the definition of lettering — I was so confused!
That is why I wanted to write about it, so hopefully, I will spare YOU the confusion, and we can learn the difference between Calligraphy, lettering, and typography, so we can call what we are doing by their real name =]
Why writing this post?
While we visited Chile this year, I was able to interview my Chilean lettering pal Leo Calderon, and during that time we were able to talk letters (video interview coming soon), and one of the things we talked about was how we both felt about the misused terms in the creative world.
PRINCIPIOS BÁSICOS . Suele confundirse los términos “Caligrafía” con “Lettering” (debido a malas enseñanzas o a traducciones mal hechas), cuando en realidad son técnicas totalmente distintas. . La Caligrafía es el arte de Escribir, pero con belleza, compuesta de un trazo y que no se puede corregir; mientras que el Lettering es el Dibujo de una letra, hecha de múltiples trazos, que dan la opción de corregir. ???? . Un aporte al buen aprendizaje de este oficio ❤ #chile #calligraphy #calligraphymasters #goodtype #lettering #typenerd #typography #typeverything #thedailytype
That is why I want to start my lettering series from the ground up. It’s doesn't make sense if I start sharing lettering and calligraphy tips and tutorials, without first covering the very foundation of terminology and letter construction.
And if I get one of you to start using the correct word, my mission would be accomplished =]
If you are still reading, THANK YOU!
I know this was a long one!
Want to save this post for later? Just pin any of the images below:
Ps. If you guys have any specific topic or question, you would like me to cover for the upcoming post; just contact me!